Things not to say to someone diagnosed with cancer (or any other medical condition) ... and what to say instead

Dr. Aurelie Lucette • Jul 29, 2020

Raise your hand if you’ve ever had a loved one, friend, colleague, neighbor diagnosed with cancer or another life-altering medical condition. Yup, that’s most of us.



When illness strikes someone close to us, we may feel sad, angry, overwhelmed by fear. Sometimes we feel shocked. Guilty. Numb. {Fill in the blank}. And because we are human beings and that we care deeply, witnessing (or even imagining) the pain that comes with a loved one's medical condition can be paralyzing. 



What should I say? What can I do?



We try and figure out the perfect time to reach out to them. We think about the right thing to say, not wanting to add to their pain or sadness or fatigue. We research the appropriate food or gift or book to bring them. 



That same discomfort and fear of not knowing what to say or do can also resurface when our loved one receives difficult news, when they have to go into surgery, when their appearance starts to change, or when we realize that maybe they won’t get better or go back to who they were before. 



I want to offer a few ideas to reflect on that I hope will provide some guidance as well as the reassurance that you are not alone if you struggle with knowing what to say or do.

  • When a loved one is diagnosed with cancer or another life-altering medical condition, it feels like a lot is at stake. They may be suffering and it hurts to see them so vulnerable. You’re afraid to add to the pain they’re going through by saying or doing the wrong thing.

  • There’s no amount of wishful thinking or giving them space that will make your loved one’s illness go away. Nothing you say or do is going to fix their pain, but saying nothing or ignoring them may make them feel worse, or at the very least, lonely.

  • Reaching out will most likely feel uncomfortable. So, don’t wait until you feel good about reaching out or until you figure out the “perfect” thing to say (there is no such thing as perfect).

  • If you’re paralyzed by the fear of saying the wrong thing, it’s very likely because you care about them and feel empathy for what they’re going through. You’re being a human being and experiencing very real, human emotions. 



  • If a loved one or friend is dealing with a cancer diagnosis, I would bet that you are thinking about them. Let them know! 



  • There is no such thing as a perfect line when it comes to providing comfort to a loved one. Just do it. It’s about being there, showing up, being willing to sit with your discomfort to provide space for your loved one and let them be seen, just the way they are. 



If you hold the expectation that you have to make their pain disappear, you will likely feel incompetent and inadequate. Instead, remind yourself that a more realistic goal can be to provide support to your loved one and make them feel cared for and seen as they navigate this challenging time.


As I mentioned a few paragraphs ago, there is no such thing as a perfect thing to say in response to a loved one’s illness. But there are certainly some statements that may be perceived as upsetting. Below are just a few examples that many people leaving with a medical condition have reported as unhelpful (although they may help some, and it’s okay too!): 



  • “You’re going to be okay”
  • “Just think positive thoughts” or “You have to stay positive”
  • “At least it’s not {xyz}”
  • You have to look at the silver lining”
  • “Look at the bright side”

Statements that appear to prescribe positivity can feel invalidating to someone who is going through a very physically and emotionally challenging experience. It can be perceived as a sign that it’s not okay to express any emotion or thought that isn’t positive, or that such experiences are not allowed or acceptable. 


These statements may also create loneliness, when the very person you are used to confiding in is signaling that the sadness, anger, doubt that you are experiencing are not quite acceptable. This may turn into feelings of guilt for experiencing emotions deemed “negative” (“I feel bad about feeling bad”, “Maybe I shouldn’t be experiencing that much negative stuff?”).   It’s also an incredibly difficult job to perform a “happy act” on top of coping with a demanding medical condition. 


(If you’re interested in reading more about toxic positive and illness, read this and that)


  • “Everything happens for a reason”

This may or may not be true! And it’s also often not the way your loved one may be seeing this situation. They may very well be feeling angry and sad as they grieve the many losses that come with a medical condition.


  • “I don’t know how you do it” or “You’re so strong” 

Many clients I’ve worked with over the years have taken issue with this statement. "What other choice to I have?!", "This is not how I feel at all."



  • “I have an aunt who died of cancer”

Nope. This is the very last thing your loved one wants to hear about.



  • “You should try this diet; I’ve heard it can help with {symptoms/illness}”

Unless they ask for advice, it’s generally a good idea to not offer any. And if you think it might be helpful information, ask them first if it’s okay for you to share it.



If you feel guilty for saying some of these things in the past, you are not alone. And kudos to you for being willing to learn new ways to support your loved one! And if you now feel even more confused about what’s appropriate to say, read on! 



I’ll repeat myself again first by saying that there’s no perfect string of words you can say. But as a rule of thumb, it’s helpful to use words that convey empathy and validate the difficult reality of your loved one’s disease. 



In the words of Kelsey Crowe and Emily McDowell (I can’t recommend their book enough, check it out: There is no good card for this):



“Your job is to hear, not to fix someone’s worry.” And I would add that it’s also not your job to fix their pain/suffering/illness. 



What you CAN do is be there alongside them as they go through the ups and downs of life with a medical condition, by making space for them to share whatever they feel a need to share with you.


It may sound like:  


  • “That sounds really hard”
  • “It makes sense that you are feeling{ xyz}”
  • “I don’t know what you are going through but I want to be here to support you.”
  • “I love you, I’m here for you”
  • “How are you, right now?”
  • “I’m so sorry this is happening”

Other ways to show support and empathy are to listen, ask questions and monitor their responses, let them tell you as much or as little as they want/need, show compassion. Be the awesome human being they’ve gotten to like over the years!



And show some compassion for yourself as well.



Having a loved one diagnosed with cancer or chronic illness can bring forth difficult emotions for you (hey, you’re a human being too!). Show yourself some kindness. Take care of yourself. Seek your own support if you need to.



I am Dr. Aurelie Lucette, a clinical health psychologist who provides individual therapy in Miami and online throughout the state of Florida. I can help with issues related to anxiety, stress, sleep, and depression. I also specialize in therapy for adults living with cancer , chronic illness, chronic pain, caregiving stress.

Need help? Let's chat!
All
By Aurelie Lucette 29 Aug, 2023
All-or-nothing thinking is a way of thinking that can lead to anxiety, particularly in those living with IBS. Dr. Lucette, a CBT health psychologist in Miami, explains how this thinking trap can lead to anxiety and low self-esteem.
By Aurelie Lucette 12 Jul, 2023
Talking about IBS or other chronic illness with others often feel stressful, and sometimes overwhelming. Having a chronic illness elevator pitch allows you to communicate to others what you want them to know about your health while doing so on your own terms.
Miami psychologist teaches you a new way to manage anxiety
By Aurelie Lucette 19 Jan, 2023
Miami anxiety therapist discusses a unique way to manage anxious thoughts. Practice treating your anxious thoughts as spam and interrupt the cycle of anxiety that can lead to discomfort and panic feelings.
Share by: